Kamala and Israel
The capacity to care for more than one
This is a guest post from the JPF family by Jeffrey Kass, author of Black Batwoman v. White Jesus: and other essays from the anti-racism collection.
All future stories written by Reuben Salsa (every Thursday, 9 am Auckland time) will be for paid subscribers only. Guest posts will remain free and posted every Sunday (9 am Auckland time).
A big shout-out to my latest and greatest subscriber,
!Support my coffee addiction and illusional writing career! Pay for a subscription today! Guaranteed weirdness! Or as Lorna would say, “It’s sane and lively!”
Kamala and Israel
A Jewish acquaintance I’ve known for 13 years took to social media to blast Vice President Kamala Harris for not attending Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s speech to Congress.
Most of the time I refrain from commenting on political posts, but I decided to remind this person that J.D. Vance was also skipping the speech.
Not to mention, the numerous Israelis who were outside the Capitol protesting Bibi.
His response was that I basically am not Jewish if I vote for Harris.
I deal with enough Jew haters. The last thing I need is someone Jewish telling me my Jewishness isn’t valid because I won’t join the Trump cult.
And anyway, if disliking Bibi means you’re anti-Israel, then over half of Israeli Jews are anti-Israel.
So stop it.
After watching Netanyahu’s speech myself, I wish I had skipped it as well.
Netanyahu sounded more like he was at a political chest-beating rally more than offering any real hope, offering any signs Israel wanted to achieve peace, even if after Hamas, or promoting anything more than endless war.
Not once did Bibi mention how Palestinians deserve their own nation and how he hoped that could be achieved after Hamas.
Did Bibi think his speech would do anything to change the world for the better?
Kamala isn’t anti-Israel just because she attended a campaign event instead of listening to an Israeli version of a Trump rally.
Indeed, Kamala has continuously supported U.S. aid to Israel. She’s met with family members of the hostages taken by Hamas.
During the “Fight for Our Freedoms” College Tour, Harris was asked a question that implied Israel was committing genocide, and Harris, while empathizing with Palestinian suffering, stood firm that Hamas was unjustified in their terror campaign.
Harris has been very outspoken about the sexual abuse and rapes that Hamas perpetrated on October 7, even while college protestors deny these hard facts. She even took time out of her packed schedule to screen a documentary about it.
In Kamala’s words: “We cannot look away and we will not be silent.”
Yes, Kamala has advocated for more aid for Gazan civilians and spoken about the bad conditions in Gaza, but she’s never wavered in her stance that “the threat of Hamas poses to the people of Israel must be eliminated.”
And yes, Harris has called for a ceasefire. Yes, she’s been outspoken that Palestinian civilian death should be avoided. She’s expressed, in her words, “deep concern” for the humanitarian conditions in Gaza.
She’s been clear that “Israel and the Israeli People and the Palestinians are entitled to an equal amount of security and dignity.”
But it isn’t a denial of Israeli humanity to care about Palestinians and advocate for their humanity as well.
Society has devolved into very selfish corners these past 8 years and it has to stop.
Harris’s Jewish husband, Doug Emhoff, has been instrumental in combatting the rise in antisemitism for the Biden administration this past year:
“When Jews are targeted because of their beliefs or identity, and when Israel is singled out because of anti-Jewish hatred, that’s antisemitism and it must be condemned — and condemned unequivocally and without context.”
Since joining the Senate in 2017, Harris has been a frequent advocate of the U.S. relationship with Israel.
One of her first speeches as a Senator was to the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, where she boasted that she had introduced a resolution condemning the U.N.’s attempt to force Israel to agree to things without a negotiated peace agreement with the Palestinians.
“Peace can only come through a reconciliation of differences and that can only happen at the negotiating table,” Harris said. She knew that peace wasn’t some magic wand you wave.
Harris even encouraged her Jewish husband to install mezuzahs on the presidential residence. Those are verses from the Bible Jews post on their doorposts.
Even after she missed Netanyahu’s speech, a top aid reiterated that Harris still stands strong and that Israel has a right to defend itself and condemned the October 7 attack in the strongest possible terms.
All while stressing the need for an improvement in the humanitarian situation in Gaza.
Harris’s stance is no different than what most American Jews, 75% of whom will vote for her, believe.
That Israel has a right to survive and thrive. That Israel has an absolute right to defend itself. That Jews have a right to be in their ancestral homeland.
AND that Palestinians likewise deserve dignity. They also deserve a home. And they deserve our compassion.
I prefer leaders who have the capacity to love more than just one group.
For more articles by Jewish authors, subscribe to the JPF on Medium (click on the image below).
Substacks to follow:
ForeignLocal by
who are mapping the entirety of Jewish publications here on Substack.
I understand some people veer firmly on the side of hate. Often I feel that way too. How could there possibly be any peace with a people wanting nothing more than the total eradication of Jews from Israel. But surely we are in danger of racism when we homogenise a group of people. We see that time and time again with the Jews.
This world needs compassion. It's what we, as a people, do best.
I honestly don't know who would help Israel better in the long-term, Harris or Trump. It's not my vote, so I've remained on the fence throughout the debate. I don't live in the US but many of the JPF contributors do. I respect all their opinions and will present their view even when I disagree.
Asking for a peaceful resolution, empathy and our help to rebuild a broken nation is the least we can do. I stand firmly with Israel and will continue to call for the annihilation of Hamas.
Reuben - please spare us all from reading anything from Jeff Kass in the future. Everyone is entitled to free speech and expression here on Substack .... but what a bunch of garbage!
I refer all readers to Jon Rosen's "What Sept 11th Revealed" which appeared here on Substack (9/11/24 @ 8:06am) I also refer all readers to two referenced articles by Mr Rosen: (on radical Islam)
1. Killing in the Name by Jeffrey Herf
2. The Perennial Power of the Nakba by Hussein Aboubakr Mansour
There will no peace in the MidEast until terror tyrannical regime of Iran is defeated. Iran foments much (if not all) of the instability in the MidEast by financing all of its proxy terror groups which currently surround much of Israel. Iran's goal is to control all of the area from the Persian Gulf to the Mediterranean, and if you don't realize this, then you're an absolute moron.
Israel's war against radical Islamic terrorism (sorry Kamala) is not about Palestinian statehood or a two State solution. Rather, it sole purpose is to fight for her very survival against these modern day Haman's.
The record of our two presidential candidates couldn't be CLEARER:
The Obama, Biden and Harris (failed) MidEast foreign policy has directly led (100%) to this current scenario.
Under four years of Trump, Iran was financially crippled and NO WARS. Jerusalem is the Capital, Israel has sovereignty over the Golan Heights and the Abraham Accords!!